=====
From xeo@home.com:

simple, but beautiful
=====
From manorton@tcnet.net:
Very well done.  The glass is great, and I love the whole backdrop.

Where is the water though?  I dont think its better.  :)

=====
From jerry@hoboes.com:
Getting a bit away from the theme here. I suppose you could call it "red water"
since you're from France :*)
=====
From Sean_Hamilton@amrcorp.com:
Simple and gorgeous.  I'm a fan of moray lathe objects too, but i never made 'em 
that good!  The color of the wine is perfect.  the only problem I see is the effects
conversion had on the background gradient. I'll be rerendering this on my own 
and pulling apart your lathes! :) 

=====
From amason@cs.uct.ac.za:
composition could be better.
models are nice, but scene lacks interest
not very original
not much to do with water if you ask me ;)
=====
From paul.flanzy@jouy.inra.fr:
Concept, originality, interpretation of theme typiquement français je suis moi meme
français !!!!!

=====
From bsieker@techfak.uni-bielefeld.de:
Very stylish and polished image. However the liquid looks not really like
water, more like wine (although wine is made up mostly of water, some alcohol
and very little coloring and flavouring substances)

=====
From johnson@pharmacy.arizona.edu:
The theme is _water_, not liquid. If you're going for a water-to-wine theme, you'll need some loaves, fishes and a messiah or two...

=====
From jaime@ctav.es:
Very nice glass, but I can't see WATER...

=====
From Varyk@aol.com:
where's the water?

=====
From gmccarter@hotmail.com:
Classy, but it looks more like wine than water...

=====
From ethelm@bigfoot.com:
A particularly artistic and attractive image, simple and elegant.
The connection with the subject of 'water' is a bit thin though.
This is one of the most elegant images we have ever seen in the IRTC competition.

=====
From chipr@niestu.com:
Very attractive still-life.  Nice colors.  May be better than water, but it
isn't, after all, water, now is it? <grin>


=====
From r@203.102.40.35:
nice glass texture and modelling. Not a lot to do with topic