=====
From :
I'd like to see more detail, and the stained glass might be helped with a normal
in the texture.
=====
From batronyx@cadronhsa.com:
The radiosity came out great! The camera angle is a bit wide though, skewing the
structure at the corner of the scene, but you probably already noticed that.
:)

=====
From johnson@pharmacy.arizona.edu:
Nice, though doing some volumetric effects with the light coming through the
window would have kicked this up a level or two.

=====
From StephenF@whoever.com:
There's some good work here, and the scene has a lot 
of potential.  I especially like the stained-glass window.  
Most of the objects look good, although the candle 
flames could use a little work.  The scene really cries 
out for more complex textures, though, especially the 
walls, floor, and the stones around the main window.  
(Personally, I would add a strip of carpet running up the 
center of the aisle, too.)  Also, are you using anti-
aliasing at all?  Using a setting of 0.1 should help clear 
up some of the jaggy edges.  Overall, though, this is 
very nice as is... I just think a little additional work could 
take it to a whole new level. (If you ever manage to find 
the time, that is!)  Looking forward to seeing more work 
from the artist.

=====
From tom@tomandlu.co.uk:
Very nice window - I sympathise with the family 
commitments. Some more detailed texturing on the walls 
would go a long way in improving the image.

=====
From chris_hormann@gmx.de:
Nice picture, the lightig looks realistic as it is, but radiosity may
have helped too.

=====
From youknow@ucan.foad.org:
For some reason, possibly because I associate this type of stained
glass with well-decorated Catholic churches, it seems a bit plain. Still, 
adding much more could easily have ruined the effect, drawn the eyes
away from the central image. Possibly what it needs is a slightly (but
not too much so) closer focus on the stained glass, which is itself
well done.

=====
From albiaprime@aol.com:
Artistic: Very nice!  Your room looks very realistic
Technical: Great job on the stained glass window. I was going to enter a similar
scene but got bogged down on the window. Bravo to you!
Concept: Fit the topic
PS I too thought there would be a lot of churches etc, strange how this round
turned out.  My mosque, like your scene, is one is not as common as one would
have thought!!!

=====
From delfeld@mailcity.com:
Epistemology:

Axiology:

Ontology: