INTERNET RAY TRACING COMPETITION Voting form for September-October 2006 This Round's Topic: Absence ---------------------------- REGISTRATION ------------ If you have already registered with the IRTC, enter your registration email address and password on the lines below. Make sure to keep the ">>>>> Registration ..." marker on the same line as your information. >>>>> Registration E-Mail Address: >>>>> Registration Password: Votes will be accepted from entrants and panel judges during the period 10 Nov 2006 -- 24 Nov 2006. Comments are accepted at any time. If you have not yet registered, you may do so either of two ways: 1. Go to "http://www.irtc.org/register.html", the registration WWW page, and follow the instructions. 2. Send an email message to "irtc-vreg@irtc.org" containing a single line in the following format: your_email_address your_password Your email address should be of the form "username@address". Your password is any string you choose. Neither the address nor the password may contain spaces. Separate the address from the password by at least one space. Note that votes will only be accepted from those who entered an image in this round, or from members of the judging panel. See our ftp or web site for information about joining the panel. RATING THE IMAGES ----------------- Please download ALL the images listed below, and view each one before rating it. For each image, give it a rating between 1 and 20 (inclusive) in each of the three listed categories. 1 is the lowest rating, and 20 is the highest. Place each number at the end of its line which starts "Rate image.jpg for ..." IMAGES ------ The images, description files, and source files may be retrieved via ftp from "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/2006-10-31". We encourage you to add comments to the images below, giving your opinions on the images, what you liked, what you didn't like, and so forth. Place your comments between the lines with the ">>>>> Comments on ..." and ">>>>> End Comments on ..." markers. You may enter as many lines as you like. NOTE: your comments will be signed with your voter email address. image: 5missing.jpg by Nimish Ajmani (106662 bytes) Description: 5missing.txt Source File: (none given) Rate 5missing.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate 5missing.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate 5missing.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on 5missing.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on 5missing.jpg image: 836.jpg by Matthew Milton (30997 bytes) Description: 836.txt Source File: (none given) Rate 836.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate 836.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate 836.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on 836.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on 836.jpg image: abesence3.jpg by Christopher Greydanus (53011 bytes) Description: abesence3.txt Source File: (none given) Rate abesence3.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate abesence3.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate abesence3.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on abesence3.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on abesence3.jpg image: absence.jpg by Charles H. Rousseau (79846 bytes) Description: absence.txt Source File: (none given) Rate absence.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absence.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absence.jpg image: absence1.jpg by Bruno P (52511 bytes) Description: absence1.txt Source File: absence1.zip Rate absence1.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence1.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence1.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absence1.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absence1.jpg image: absence2.jpg by Bruno P (78618 bytes) Description: absence2.txt Source File: absence2.zip Rate absence2.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence2.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence2.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absence2.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absence2.jpg image: absence_.jpg by J H (235760 bytes) Description: absence_.txt Source File: (none given) Rate absence_.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence_.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absence_.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absence_.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absence_.jpg image: absencep.jpg by Bryce Leach (22541 bytes) Description: absencep.txt Source File: (none given) Rate absencep.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absencep.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absencep.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absencep.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absencep.jpg image: absentdu.jpg by Patrick D. Neary (113460 bytes) Description: absentdu.txt Source File: (none given) Rate absentdu.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absentdu.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absentdu.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absentdu.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absentdu.jpg image: absincep.jpg by kohle mcleod (46514 bytes) Description: absincep.txt Source File: (none given) Rate absincep.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate absincep.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate absincep.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on absincep.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on absincep.jpg image: anthonym.jpg by Anthony Mallon (63476 bytes) Description: anthonym.txt Source File: (none given) Rate anthonym.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate anthonym.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate anthonym.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on anthonym.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on anthonym.jpg image: blakesab.jpg by Blake (80306 bytes) Description: blakesab.txt Source File: (none given) Rate blakesab.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate blakesab.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate blakesab.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on blakesab.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on blakesab.jpg image: blocks.jpg by Matt Roberts (223748 bytes) Description: blocks.txt Source File: blocks.zip Rate blocks.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate blocks.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate blocks.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on blocks.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on blocks.jpg image: bridge.jpg by John Lamb (172265 bytes) Description: bridge.txt Source File: (none given) Rate bridge.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate bridge.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate bridge.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on bridge.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on bridge.jpg image: cf_paper.jpg by Christian Froeschlin (92611 bytes) Description: cf_paper.txt Source File: cf_paper.zip Rate cf_paper.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate cf_paper.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate cf_paper.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on cf_paper.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on cf_paper.jpg image: chrisabs.jpg by Chirs McDonald (40257 bytes) Description: chrisabs.txt Source File: (none given) Rate chrisabs.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate chrisabs.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate chrisabs.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on chrisabs.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on chrisabs.jpg image: chrispre.jpg by Chris T. Pressley (134472 bytes) Description: chrispre.txt Source File: (none given) Rate chrispre.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate chrispre.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate chrispre.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on chrispre.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on chrispre.jpg image: colerobe.jpg by Cole (65785 bytes) Description: colerobe.txt Source File: (none given) Rate colerobe.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate colerobe.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate colerobe.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on colerobe.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on colerobe.jpg image: colinipa.jpg by Colin Ip (65488 bytes) Description: colinipa.txt Source File: (none given) Rate colinipa.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate colinipa.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate colinipa.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on colinipa.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on colinipa.jpg image: dadgift.jpg by Stephen Lumini (239090 bytes) Description: dadgift.txt Source File: (none given) Rate dadgift.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dadgift.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dadgift.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dadgift.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dadgift.jpg image: dogbowl2.jpg by Matt LaVere (211723 bytes) Description: dogbowl2.txt Source File: (none given) Rate dogbowl2.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dogbowl2.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dogbowl2.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dogbowl2.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dogbowl2.jpg image: dtd.jpg by Thomas de Groot (227197 bytes) Description: dtd.txt Source File: dtd.zip Rate dtd.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dtd.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dtd.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dtd.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dtd.jpg image: dv_light.jpg by Daniel Volk (154797 bytes) Description: dv_light.txt Source File: dv_light.zip Rate dv_light.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate dv_light.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate dv_light.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on dv_light.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on dv_light.jpg image: eabsence.jpg by Aitzol Muelas Cortabarria (160675 bytes) Description: eabsence.txt Source File: (none given) Rate eabsence.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate eabsence.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate eabsence.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on eabsence.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on eabsence.jpg image: emperor.jpg by Scott Gatchell (156832 bytes) Description: emperor.txt Source File: (none given) Rate emperor.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate emperor.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate emperor.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on emperor.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on emperor.jpg image: ethanabs.jpg by Ethan (55880 bytes) Description: ethanabs.txt Source File: (none given) Rate ethanabs.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate ethanabs.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate ethanabs.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on ethanabs.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on ethanabs.jpg image: fc_room.jpg by Fatima Cvrckova (166693 bytes) Description: fc_room.txt Source File: fc_room.zip Rate fc_room.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate fc_room.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate fc_room.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on fc_room.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on fc_room.jpg image: is_beach.jpg by Ionita Sebastian (251977 bytes) Description: is_beach.txt Source File: (none given) Rate is_beach.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate is_beach.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate is_beach.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on is_beach.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on is_beach.jpg image: is_life.jpg by Ionita Sebastian (118600 bytes) Description: is_life.txt Source File: (none given) Rate is_life.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate is_life.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate is_life.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on is_life.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on is_life.jpg image: kaa_crmn.jpg by Andrey K. (115472 bytes) Description: kaa_crmn.txt Source File: kaa_crmn.zip Rate kaa_crmn.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate kaa_crmn.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate kaa_crmn.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on kaa_crmn.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on kaa_crmn.jpg image: kickassa.jpg by Alex Arend (104054 bytes) Description: kickassa.txt Source File: (none given) Rate kickassa.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate kickassa.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate kickassa.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on kickassa.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on kickassa.jpg image: kj_late.jpg by Kyle Johnson (228514 bytes) Description: kj_late.txt Source File: (none given) Rate kj_late.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate kj_late.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate kj_late.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on kj_late.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on kj_late.jpg image: missing.jpg by Sean Day (251741 bytes) Description: missing.txt Source File: missing.zip Rate missing.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate missing.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate missing.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on missing.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on missing.jpg image: modelopa.jpg by Antonio Sanhueza Bahamonde (235745 bytes) Description: modelopa.txt Source File: (none given) Rate modelopa.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate modelopa.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate modelopa.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on modelopa.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on modelopa.jpg image: my_tooth.jpg by Michael Hunter (216037 bytes) Description: my_tooth.txt Source File: (none given) Rate my_tooth.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate my_tooth.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate my_tooth.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on my_tooth.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on my_tooth.jpg image: nofriend.jpg by Helene Dumur (160321 bytes) Description: nofriend.txt Source File: (none given) Rate nofriend.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate nofriend.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate nofriend.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on nofriend.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on nofriend.jpg image: nopaper.jpg by Roy Rodriguez (243007 bytes) Description: nopaper.txt Source File: nopaper.zip Rate nopaper.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate nopaper.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate nopaper.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on nopaper.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on nopaper.jpg image: patricia.jpg by Patricia McKenzie (21620 bytes) Description: patricia.txt Source File: (none given) Rate patricia.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate patricia.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate patricia.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on patricia.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on patricia.jpg image: peace.jpg by Oliver Kessler (182893 bytes) Description: peace.txt Source File: (none given) Rate peace.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate peace.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate peace.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on peace.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on peace.jpg image: rev_man.jpg by Michael Hunter (107099 bytes) Description: rev_man.txt Source File: (none given) Rate rev_man.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate rev_man.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate rev_man.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on rev_man.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on rev_man.jpg image: runaway.jpg by Rob Fitzel (234577 bytes) Description: runaway.txt Source File: (none given) Rate runaway.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate runaway.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate runaway.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on runaway.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on runaway.jpg image: salty.jpg by Chris Fick (102628 bytes) Description: salty.txt Source File: (none given) Rate salty.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate salty.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate salty.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on salty.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on salty.jpg image: scotthan.jpg by Scott Hanson (22909 bytes) Description: scotthan.txt Source File: (none given) Rate scotthan.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate scotthan.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate scotthan.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on scotthan.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on scotthan.jpg image: smh_puzz.jpg by Stacy Michelle Haponik (236127 bytes) Description: smh_puzz.txt Source File: smh_puzz.zip Rate smh_puzz.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate smh_puzz.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate smh_puzz.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on smh_puzz.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on smh_puzz.jpg image: soabsent.jpg by Diego Magnani (164391 bytes) Description: soabsent.txt Source File: (none given) Rate soabsent.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate soabsent.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate soabsent.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on soabsent.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on soabsent.jpg image: sol.jpg by Brian Blovett (225827 bytes) Description: sol.txt Source File: sol.zip Rate sol.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate sol.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate sol.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on sol.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on sol.jpg image: techess.jpg by Thomas Efer (244494 bytes) Description: techess.txt Source File: techess.zip Rate techess.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate techess.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate techess.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on techess.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on techess.jpg image: thethief.jpg by Jason Knight (246330 bytes) Description: thethief.txt Source File: thethief.zip Rate thethief.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate thethief.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate thethief.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on thethief.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on thethief.jpg image: waiting.jpg by Ian MacKay (169398 bytes) Description: waiting.txt Source File: (none given) Rate waiting.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate waiting.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate waiting.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on waiting.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on waiting.jpg image: watch.jpg by Andrew Herron (34052 bytes) Description: watch.txt Source File: (none given) Rate watch.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate watch.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate watch.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on watch.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on watch.jpg image: wp_ghost.jpg by Bill Pragnell (193893 bytes) Description: wp_ghost.txt Source File: wp_ghost.zip Rate wp_ghost.jpg for artistic merit (1 .. 20): Rate wp_ghost.jpg for technical merit (1 .. 20): Rate wp_ghost.jpg for concept, originality, interpretation of theme (1 .. 20): >>>>> Comments on wp_ghost.jpg: >>>>> End Comments on wp_ghost.jpg ADDITIONAL COMMENTS ------------------- If you would like to add comments which are not related to any specific image, place them below, between the lines with the ">>>>>" markers: >>>>> Additional Comments: >>>>> End Additional Comments: SUBMITTING YOUR VOTE -------------------- For your vote to be accepted, you must rate every image in all three categories, except for your own image(s), if you entered this round. Once you have rated the images, and added any comments you might have, either email this form to "irtc-vote@irtc.org", or upload it via anonymous ftp to "ftp://ftp.irtc.org/pub/stills/vote". Votes will be accepted during the period 10 Nov 2006 -- 24 Nov 2006. You will be notified at your voter email address once your vote has been processed. (Leave these lines alone!) >>>>> Competition subdivision: stills >>>>> Competition Period: 2006-10-31 >>>>> End Form